Maclean's Non-Fiction Bestseller

In this book, as in his reviews, Scott's voice is genial, reasonable and self-aware. He elucidates complex ideas with snappy language. He's funny, but not cynical or snarky.... What he does especially well is explain how art develops and why our varied responses to it matter, pinpointing where criticism fits into the equation. - Newsday

Mr. Scott is very intelligent....What may matter more is that Mr. Scott is fun to read...[Scott] says that the simple questions-always with complex answers-that criticism poses are: 'Did you feel that?' 'Was it good for you?' 'Tell the Truth.' He reminds us that critical judgments, like art itself, demand intellectual and sensuous, even sexual, responses. Mr. Scott answers his own demands....- Wall Street Journal

Rousing and erudite.- San Francisco Chronicle

Witty and thoughtful.... Reading Scott's book is like watching the stiff-upper-lipped hero of a British 1940s thriller facing down his or her adversaries - modest, brave and utterly unflappable.- LA Times

If we were looking for an intelligent, informed and often funny account of why we can't live comfortably with criticism (in any of the word's meanings), and can't live without it, either, we need look no further, and shall probably want to read this book more than once....- New York Times

Impassioned and deeply thoughtful ....Scott lays out a taxonomy of meaningful thought (and the meaning of thought itself)....His disciplined reasoning, impressive erudition, and deep commitment to his art (as he defines it) are never less than provocative and elegantly articulated. A zealous and well-considered work of advocacy for an art too often unappreciated and misunderstood.- Kirkus

This stunning treatise on criticism from New York Times film critic Scott is a complete success, comprehensively demonstrating the value of his art...a necessary work that may enter the canon of great criticism. - Publisher's Weekly starred review

From the Hardcover edition.